The Ham and English Pea Circuit | The Interstate Compact vs The People

Sliced ham on a platter beside a drinking glass.
Photo by Jake Warren on Unsplash

If you wanted to be governor of Georgia in 1958, it helped if you liked ham. Ernest Vandiver ate enough of it to give that part of his political education a name. His wife, Betty, remembered him calling it the “ham and English pea circuit.” You made a speech. Somebody fed you ham and peas. The next town wanted a speech, too. You could probably guess what was for dinner.

When Ernie ran for governor, Betty’s mother came to stay with the children. As Betty put it, “Mama moved in and I moved out.” She and Ernie flew to Dublin, Georgia, for his opening rally on July 12. Betty had never seen a rally that big. Between the county seats, they stopped in the little towns. An hour and a half, maybe two hours, and you could walk into every store in town, hand somebody a campaign folder, introduce yourself, and tell them what you were doing there.

Why spend two hours in a town small enough that you could introduce yourself to every shopkeeper? Well, Ernie wanted to be governor. And Georgia counted counties.

Win Fulton County, home to Atlanta, and you got six units toward the Democratic nomination. Win Echols, Glascock, and Quitman, the three smallest counties in Georgia, and you got six units, too. The 1960 census counted more than half a million people in Fulton. Those other three had fewer than seven thousand people put together. You can see why Ernie got out of the car.

You could tell where a candidate needed support by listening to which roads he promised to fix. Under the county system, men running for governor promised rural roads and bridges. They had a good deal less to say about traffic in Atlanta. Come election time, a county could deliver its two units. Come road-building time, the state highway board could reward that county with a contract or make it wait. Vandiver remembered people joking that you knew when you’d crossed the Georgia line because the ride got bumpy. He figured his predecessors had put so much into rural roads that some of the main highways had suffered.

You can see why somebody in Atlanta wanted the rules changed. Georgia’s system diluted the political power of Black voters and helped sustain segregation. Vandiver himself campaigned to keep the schools segregated. He won in a landslide in 1958, the last governor Georgia elected under the county-unit system. Four years later, while he was still governor, a federal court blocked the system. The next time Georgians chose a Democratic nominee for governor, the candidate who got the most votes statewide won.

In 1972, Ernie wanted to go to Washington as a United States senator. This time the Vandivers had a campaign van. Their children were old enough to help, and Betty remembered the young people working out of headquarters in Atlanta while she and Ernie were on the road. Campaigns used television a good deal more by then. Still, the Vandivers set out to visit every county in Georgia. Betty said they made it.

Which brings us back to Echols County. A woman was voting absentee at the courthouse. She was friendly to Ernie and Betty, and as long as she had the ballot in her hands, Betty had every reason to think the visit was going pretty well. Then the woman folded it. Betty caught a glimpse. Vandiver was down at the bottom of the ballot. The woman had put her mark up near the top. She’d voted for Sam Nunn.

She owed Ernie Vandiver nothing, and by Betty’s account, that’s about how many votes she gave him. Good for her.

Ernie lost. He finished third in the Democratic primary and missed the runoff. That was his last race. Years later, looking back on the two ways he’d run for office, he remembered how much time candidates used to spend in rural Georgia. He also knew where a man who wanted to win now had to go. In his words, “if you want to get elected, you’ve got to spend your time and your money and your efforts in the metropolitan areas.”

And what happened to the roads? In the years that followed, Georgia gradually put more state money into urban roads and bridges and gave more support to public transit. If you rode the bus to work, you had good reason to want the governor to hear from you. So did the farmer whose truck had to cross a county bridge. After the speeches and the dinners and the election, somebody still had to decide which road to fix first.

Today, the people of Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada face a choice about how Americans elect a president. Last week, voters in all five states gave Democrats the governorship and majorities in both houses of the legislature. Between them, those five states have enough electoral votes to put the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact into effect.

The Compact going into effect would essentially nullify the Electoral College.

Now, on paper we should be for everybody’s vote counting. One person, one vote. Someone who raises beef cattle in Wisconsin shouldn’t get more say in choosing a president than someone who rides the bus to work in Milwaukee. But we also want a president who can serve the interests of the entire nation.

One of our national goals is justice. If we don’t listen to the entire country, how can we set conditions so kids who grow up in projects and trailers everywhere can work to achieve prosperity?

And some of the things the entire nation depends on happen in places where very few people live. What reason will a candidate have to go there and hear what those people have to say?

Here’s what those five states could join. Each state that joins the compact agrees to give all its electoral votes to the presidential ticket that gets the most votes across the country. The agreement takes effect when the states that join hold enough electoral votes to elect a president. Today that takes 270. Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have joined. Together they have 222. Pennsylvania and Michigan, plus any two of Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada, would get them there. All five would bring the total to 283.

What would that change? Say Wisconsin voters choose one candidate and the country chooses the other. Today, the candidate who wins Wisconsin gets its ten electoral votes. If Wisconsin joins and the compact takes effect, all ten would go to the candidate who lost Wisconsin and won the most votes nationwide.

Now put yourself in Wisconsin the Saturday before a presidential election. The popular vote already matters. To carry Wisconsin, you have to get more votes than anybody else in Wisconsin. In 2024, Kamala Harris carried Milwaukee County by a wide margin. Donald Trump won the state by 29,397 votes. If you’re the Democrat, how many votes can you afford to lose in rural Wisconsin? If you’re the Republican, how many people in Milwaukee can you afford to write off? When a state is that close, both candidates have a reason to listen in both places. An extra ten thousand votes in New York won’t help either one of them carry Wisconsin.

Now change the rules. Say you lose ten thousand votes in rural Wisconsin and pick up eleven thousand in New York City. You come out a thousand ahead. It works the other way, too. You could make up a loss in New York by picking up votes in rural Wisconsin. The question is where you spend that last Saturday. If your campaign figures it can pick up more votes in the city, what reason do you have to spend those two hours on a county road? And when the winner sits down with Congress to work on the next highway bill, whose roads did that president spend the campaign promising to fix?

A president has to hear the whole country, not only the places where it’s efficient to gather votes.

When winning depends on running up totals in a few dense places, issues that live in thin places fade from the conversation. And when those issues fade, the union weakens, because people feel unheard and problems go unsolved.

Take the price of beef. If you’re standing at a meat counter in New York City, you have a perfectly good question. Why does beef cost this much? If you raise beef cattle in Wisconsin, you may be standing over a feed bill trying to decide whether to keep a heifer. Calves are bringing a lot of money right now. Sell her and you get a big check. Keep her and you have to feed her while you wait for her to have a calf. What does the hay cost? Can you afford to keep her? If enough farmers decide they can’t, how many calves will they have to sell a few years down the road? What do you suppose that means for the person standing at the meat counter?

Both people have a stake in the answer. Only one of them has to buy the hay. When the Constitution speaks of promoting the general welfare, that includes the ability of both families to make a living and put food on the table. And the people who have to buy the hay will never outnumber the people who buy groceries. A candidate could spend every Saturday between now and the election talking to shoppers about the price of beef. How good an answer could the next president give them without understanding why a Wisconsin farmer might decide to sell that heifer?

Betty figured it took two hours to walk into every store in one of those little Georgia towns. Two hours is a long time for a presidential candidate. It’s long enough for somebody who buys hay to explain a thing or two about the price of beef.

If the candidate drives on by, who loses those two hours?

The Wisconsin farmer, sure.

And if you’re standing at that meat counter in New York wondering why beef costs this much, so do you.

Joel K. Douglas signature

Sources

Betty Vandiver’s oral history, including the dinners, campaign stops, and Echols County ballot

https://dlg.usg.edu/record/gych_rbrl096hph_ohvan13b-0045

https://dlg.usg.edu/record/gych_rbrl096hph_ohvan13c-0046

Dublin campaign rally, July 12, 1958

https://sclfind.libs.uga.edu/catalog/RBRL186SEV_aspace_ref1363_rqo

Ernest Vandiver’s oral history and political career

https://dlg.usg.edu/record/gych_rbrl096hph_ohvan04e-0031

https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/government-politics/ernest-vandiver-jr-1918-2005/

Georgia’s county-unit system and the Supreme Court’s account of the population figures in Gray v. Sanders

https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/counties-cities-neighborhoods/county-unit-system/

https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-372/pdf/USREPORTS-372-368.pdf

Georgia’s historic transportation study, including rural county contracts and the shift in urban transportation funding

https://dca.georgia.gov/document/document/historic-transportation-context-1955-1965-draft/download

Compact text, electoral votes, and November 2026 status

https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacodeupdates/title24.2/section24.2-209.1/

https://www.ncsl.org/elections-and-campaigns/national-popular-vote

https://www.archives.gov/electoral-college/allocation

https://apnews.com/article/ac5d917e582ee02e813615a91c6a1f5c

https://www.nationalpopularvote.com/midterm-election-results-5-states-provide-way-national-popular-vote-reach-270-during-2027

Wisconsin’s certified 2024 presidential results and county returns

https://apnews.com/article/735a9a394a48ca2ab886e153f3fc4c3b

https://apps.npr.org/2024-election-results/wisconsin.html?section=key-races